North York office, serving Scarborough, Toronto and all of Ontario Free case review: (416) 425-3042

Free Case Reviews

Short Term Disability Lawyers in Ontario

Short-term disability benefits are supposed to replace part of your income when an illness or injury keeps you off work. In Ontario, many short-term disability claims are delayed, cut off early or denied, even when your doctor supports your time away. Kadish Law helps employees across Ontario challenge denied and terminated short-term disability claims.

We take short-term disability denials

Some disability law firms only take long-term disability cases. Short-term claims are smaller and shorter, so they turn them away. We don’t. We handle short-term disability denials at every stage: the insurer’s internal appeal, a lawsuit, or both, one after the other.

A short-term disability denial matters more than its size suggests:

  • Short-term and long-term disability are usually with the same insurer, and the short-term claim file follows you into the long-term claim.
  • Long-term disability usually starts only after the short-term period ends. A denied short-term claim can make the long-term claim harder to win.
  • Without income, many people feel pushed back to work before they are ready, which can set back their recovery and their claim.

If your short-term disability was denied or cut off, request a free case review. We also offer free help with appeals of denied short-term disability claims.

Short-term disability claim denied? What to do now

  1. Get the denial letter and the insurer’s reasons in writing.
  2. Ask for a copy of the policy or benefits booklet, and for your claim file.
  3. Write down the appeal deadline in the denial letter.
  4. Ask your doctors for records that describe your functional limitations, not just your diagnosis.
  5. If you haven’t already, apply for EI sickness benefits so you have some income while the dispute is resolved.
  6. Talk to a lawyer before you file an appeal. Early strategy matters, and a poorly framed appeal can weaken your later options.

Should I appeal or start a claim?

While some disability insurance law firms require that their clients only proceed with a claim, at Kadish Law we give clients both options. You can appeal your short-term disability denial, proceed directly to a claim, or do both, one after the other.

There are advantages to both. In many ways they are opposites: the weaknesses of a claim are the strengths of an appeal, and the reverse.

Compare Internal appeal Lawsuit
Who decides The insurer A judge, independent of the insurer
Speed Often an answer within 30 to 60 days of the insurer receiving everything it needs Longer, though many claims settle along the way
Evidence A chance to fill gaps in your medical evidence Full disclosure of the insurer’s file and its reasons
Other claims Benefits only Can be combined with related claims, such as a wrongful dismissal

Many clients first try an appeal. If it is not successful, and they usually find out quickly, we can help bring a claim for the twice-denied benefits.

What is short-term disability in Ontario?

Short-term disability, often called STD, is usually an employer-sponsored insurance benefit. It pays a portion of your income for a limited period if you cannot work for medical reasons. Ontario employers are not required by law to offer it.

Some employers buy an insured plan from an insurance company. Others fund the benefits themselves and pay an insurer only to administer the claims. The difference matters, because it affects who you would sue.

Short-term disability is not the same as other income supports:

Benefit Who provides it How long it usually lasts Main test
Short-term disability Your employer’s plan or its insurer Depends on the plan, commonly 3, 6 or 12 months You can’t perform the essential duties of your own job
EI sickness benefits The federal government Up to 26 weeks You are unable to work because of illness or injury, and you have enough insured hours
Long-term disability An insurer, under a group or individual policy Often to age 65, if you stay disabled Your own job at first, then usually any suitable job after two years
WSIB benefits Ontario’s Workplace Safety and Insurance Board Varies The illness or injury is work-related

If you are unsure whether you have short-term or long-term disability coverage, ask your employer in writing to confirm it and to send you the application.

How short-term disability claims work

Most Ontario short-term disability plans require:

  • a waiting or elimination period before benefits start
  • medical evidence from your treating providers
  • regular progress updates
  • confirmation that you cannot perform the essential duties of your job

Insurers look for functional restrictions tied directly to your role. General statements like “unable to work” are often treated as insufficient. The strongest claims connect three things: your medical condition, the limitations it causes, and the actual duties of your job.

Common reasons short-term disability claims are denied

Short-term disability denials in Ontario commonly rely on:

  • alleged insufficient medical evidence
  • missed forms or deadlines
  • pre-existing condition exclusions
  • the insurer’s opinion that you can work with restrictions
  • mental health claims that lack functional detail
  • surveillance or social media reviews
  • conflicting opinions between your doctors and the insurer’s reviewers

A denial usually reflects how the insurer interprets the policy, not whether you are actually able to work.

Short-term disability and mental health claims

Many short-term disability claims in Ontario involve anxiety, depression, burnout, PTSD and other stress-related conditions. Claims for depression and anxiety are among the most common we help with.

Mental health claims are valid under short-term disability plans, but insurers often demand clear evidence of how your symptoms affect concentration, attendance, decision-making or the interaction your job requires. Insurers sometimes say that notes from your family doctor or specialist are not “objective medical evidence”. Courts have recognized that mental health conditions can be just as disabling as physical ones, even without a blood test or scan to prove them.

Short-term disability denied, and long-term disability next

Most long-term disability policies have a qualifying period, often 17 or 26 weeks, that matches the length of the short-term plan. When the short-term claim is denied, the insurer will often rely on the same reasons to deny long-term disability later.

Two practical points:

  • Apply for long-term disability on time, even while your short-term claim is in dispute. Missing the long-term application deadline can create a separate problem.
  • Build your short-term evidence with the long-term claim in mind. The same records will be read again.

We handle long-term disability claims too, so both claims can be managed together.

Can you be fired while on short-term disability in Ontario?

Your employer cannot fire you because of a disability. Under the Ontario Human Rights Code, employers have a duty to accommodate employees with disabilities, up to the point of undue hardship. Terminations do sometimes happen during medical leave, and are later justified on other grounds.

If this happens to you, you may have both an insurance dispute over your benefits and an employment claim for wrongful dismissal or discrimination. These should be handled together, not separately. We act on both. See our page for employment lawyers for employees and our article on whether your employer can force you back to work from sick leave.

Short-term disability deadlines

Short-term disability plans often impose strict timelines for:

  • the initial application
  • medical updates
  • internal appeals, which can be as short as a few weeks

To sue, Ontario generally allows two years, usually counted from when the claim was denied. When the clock starts can be disputed, and some policies contain their own time limits, so don’t wait. Missing a deadline can limit or end your ability to challenge the insurer’s decision.

Where a short-term disability claim is heard

Since October 1, 2025, Ontario’s Small Claims Court hears claims of up to $50,000. Many short-term disability claims fall within that limit, and Small Claims Court is generally faster and less costly than the Superior Court. Larger claims, or short-term claims combined with long-term disability or wrongful dismissal claims, go to the Superior Court of Justice.

What to bring to your free case review

  • The denial or termination letter
  • Your policy or benefits booklet, if you have it
  • Your application forms and any letters from the insurer
  • Medical notes, reports and records of treatment
  • Your job description
  • Any messages from your employer about your leave or your return to work

Short-term disability lawyers in North York, Scarborough and across Ontario

Kadish Law represents employees in North York, Scarborough, Toronto, the GTA and across Ontario in denied and terminated short-term disability claims. In-person and virtual meetings are available.

Our work includes disability insurance disputes, terminations during medical leave, and human rights and accommodation issues. We regularly act for professionals, managers and employees facing pressure to return to work before they are medically able.

We serve clients across Ontario, including North York, Scarborough, Toronto, the Greater Toronto Area, Ottawa, Brampton, Mississauga, Hamilton, London, Markham, Vaughan, Kitchener and Windsor.

Short-term disability FAQs

How long does short-term disability last in Ontario?

It depends on the plan. The most common periods are 3, 6 and 12 months. Some employers provide no short-term disability at all, and rely on EI sickness benefits until long-term disability starts.

What percentage of salary does short-term disability pay?

Most plans pay a percentage of your earnings, up to a maximum set by the policy. Common levels are 50%, 60%, 66.67%, 75% and 100%. Some plans pay one level for a period, then drop to a lower one.

Can I be fired while on short-term disability?

You cannot be fired because of your disability. If your employer ends your job during your leave, you may have claims for both your benefits and your job. Talk to a lawyer before you sign anything.

Is short-term disability the same as EI sickness benefits?

No. Short-term disability is usually an employer-sponsored insurance benefit. EI sickness benefits are a federal program that pays for up to 26 weeks.

Can the insurer require a medical assessment?

Many plans allow the insurer to request an assessment, but there are limits, and how you approach it matters. Get advice before you attend.

Do I need a lawyer to appeal a short-term disability denial?

No, but it helps. An appeal is usually your best chance to fix gaps in the evidence, and what you submit can be used against you later. We offer free help with appeals of denied short-term disability claims.

Can I sue the insurer for denying my short-term disability?

Yes. If your benefits were wrongly denied, you can sue for them. You usually don’t have to finish the internal appeal first, though it is often worth trying.

Is short-term disability taxable?

It depends on who paid the premiums. If your employer paid them, the benefits are generally taxable. If you paid them with after-tax money, they generally are not.

My benefits were cut off when I tried to go back to work. What now?

A failed return to work can support your claim, because it shows you tried. Keep records of what happened, and get advice before the insurer closes your file.

Not sure if you have a case?

Ask us. The first review is free, and there’s no obligation.

Call us Free case review