North York office, serving Scarborough, Toronto and all of Ontario Free case review: (416) 425-3042

Free Case Reviews

What Are My Options if My Manulife Short-Term Disability Claim Is Denied?

If Manulife denied your short-term disability claim, you usually have several options: ask for the full reasons and your file, file an internal appeal, make a complaint, or start a lawsuit. Which is best depends on your plan and the reason for the denial.

Kadish Law is not affiliated with Manulife. This page explains the general options available to employees in Ontario.

Step 1: Find out who actually pays

Manulife may insure your employer’s short-term disability plan, or it may only administer a plan your employer pays for itself. The difference matters, because it affects who you would sue. Ask your employer or check your benefits booklet.

Step 2: Get the reasons and your file

Ask in writing for:

  • the full reasons for the denial;
  • a copy of the policy or plan document; and
  • your complete claim file, including any medical reviews.

Step 3: Choose your route

Option What it involves
Internal appeal Send new evidence and ask Manulife to reconsider, within the deadline in your letter
Complaint Use the insurer’s complaint process, and then the OmbudService for Life & Health Insurance (OLHI), an independent service
Lawsuit Sue for the unpaid benefits in Small Claims Court (up to $50,000) or the Superior Court

You often don’t have to finish the internal appeal before you sue. Some steps can affect your deadlines, so get advice first.

Strengthening your claim

Short-term disability denials are often based on a lack of functional detail. Ask your doctor to describe exactly how your condition limits your ability to do your job. Read the best way to appeal a disability claim.

Don’t forget long-term disability

If your condition continues, apply for long-term disability on time, even while the short-term claim is in dispute.

We take short-term disability denials

Some firms only take long-term cases. Kadish Law handles short-term disability denials, including appeals and claims. Kadish Law offers free case reviews. Use the form on this page.

Not sure if you have a case?

Ask us. The first review is free, and there’s no obligation.

Call us Free case review