North York office, serving Scarborough, Toronto and all of Ontario Free case review: (416) 425-3042

Free Case Reviews

What Is the Best Way to Appeal a Disability Claim?

The best way to appeal a disability claim depends on why it was denied, what your policy says and how much time you have. In Ontario you usually have two options: the insurer’s internal appeal, or a lawsuit. Sometimes the best approach uses both, one after the other.

Option 1: the internal appeal

The insurer reviews its own decision.

  • It can be fast, often weeks rather than months.
  • It is a chance to fill gaps in your medical evidence.
  • The decision is still made by the insurer that denied you.
  • Some steps can affect your deadlines or later options.

Option 2: a lawsuit

You sue the insurer for the unpaid benefits.

  • A judge, not the insurer, decides.
  • You get the insurer’s full claim file.
  • You often don’t have to finish the internal appeal first.
  • It takes longer, though many claims settle along the way.

How to make an appeal succeed

  1. Get the denial letter, your policy and your full claim file.
  2. Identify exactly why the insurer said no.
  3. Ask your doctors for evidence of your functional limitations, not just your diagnosis.
  4. Connect your limitations to the actual duties of your job.
  5. Respond to every point the insurer raised.
  6. Keep copies of everything you send.

Deadlines

Internal appeal deadlines are set by your policy and can be short. Lawsuits generally must start within two years, but when the clock starts can be disputed, so don’t wait.

CPP disability appeals are different

For CPP disability, you first ask for a reconsideration, usually within 90 days of the decision, and then appeal to the Social Security Tribunal.

Get advice before you appeal

At Kadish Law, we give clients both options: we can handle your appeal, go straight to a claim, or do both. See our pages on short-term disability and long-term disability. Kadish Law offers free case reviews. Use the form on this page.

Not sure if you have a case?

Ask us. The first review is free, and there’s no obligation.

Call us Free case review