What actually drives the value of a claim
| Factor | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Severity and permanence of the injury | The biggest driver of pain and suffering damages |
| Lost income | Past and future earnings, which depend on your work and age |
| Care and treatment costs | Ongoing therapy, medication, attendant care and home changes |
| Who was at fault | Your own share of fault can reduce the award |
| Available insurance | What can actually be collected |
| Evidence | Medical records, expert reports and witnesses |
Car accidents are different
Ontario’s Insurance Act adds two rules to car accident claims:
- You can only claim pain and suffering if your injury meets the threshold of a permanent, serious impairment.
- In 2026, a statutory deductible of $47,913.01 is taken off pain and suffering awards below $159,708.71.
Accident benefits from your own insurer are a separate claim. Since July 1, 2026, only medical, rehabilitation and attendant care benefits are mandatory, and other benefits depend on the coverage you chose. Read how much you can sue for after a car accident.
Pain and suffering has a ceiling
For the most catastrophic injuries, pain and suffering damages in Canada are capped by an inflation-adjusted limit set by the Supreme Court of Canada. Most claims are well below that limit. Economic losses, such as lost income and care costs, are not capped.
How to value your own claim
A lawyer values a claim by looking at your medical evidence, your income history and comparable court decisions. That gives you a realistic range, rather than an average that may not fit.
Kadish Law offers free case reviews. Use the form on this page, or read what you take home from a $100,000 settlement.