North York office, serving Scarborough, Toronto and all of Ontario Free case review: (416) 425-3042

Free Case Reviews

Can You Negotiate a Severance Payout?

Yes. In Ontario, the first severance offer is often not the employer’s final position, and many packages improve once the employee gets legal advice. How and when you negotiate matters as much as what you ask for.

When a severance offer is negotiable

An offer is usually negotiable when:

  • your contract has no termination clause, or the clause may not be enforceable;
  • the offer is based on the Employment Standards Act minimums;
  • bonus, commission, benefits or equity are missing;
  • your employer alleged cause it may not be able to prove; or
  • there are human rights or bad faith issues in how you were let go.

If your contract has a clearly enforceable clause limiting you to the ESA minimums, there may be less room. That is why a contract review comes first.

What can be negotiated

  • The amount, and whether it is paid as a lump sum or salary continuance.
  • Bonus, commission and benefit continuation.
  • Treatment of stock options and other awards.
  • A reference letter and the explanation given for your departure.
  • The scope of the release, confidentiality and non-disparagement terms.
  • How the payment is structured for tax purposes.

How to negotiate without hurting your position

Do not sign anything on the spot. Ask in writing for time to get advice. Avoid giving your employer a range, because the lowest number becomes the ceiling. Be careful in emails: write as if a judge will read them later.

Employers tend to negotiate more seriously when a lawyer is involved, because it signals you are prepared to enforce your rights. Read how negotiating your own severance can backfire.

What if the employer refuses to move?

You can start a wrongful dismissal claim. You generally have two years from your termination to sue. Most claims settle before trial, but our lawyers take cases to trial when that is what it takes.

Senior employees should also see our page for executive severance lawyers. For everyone else, request a free case review through the form on this page.

Not sure if you have a case?

Ask us. The first review is free, and there’s no obligation.

Call us Free case review