North York office, serving Scarborough, Toronto and all of Ontario Free case review: (416) 425-3042

Free Case Reviews

What to Expect When You Hire a Lawyer for a Severance, Disability or Injury Claim in Ontario

Most people who call us have never hired a lawyer before. They have just lost a job, had disability benefits denied, or been hurt in an accident, and on top of everything else they are worried about what the legal process will involve. This article walks through what usually happens, from the first conversation to the end of a case, so you know what to expect.

Every matter is different, and this is general information rather than legal advice. But the basic stages are similar for most severance, disability and personal injury claims in Ontario.

Step 1: The first conversation

The first step is a review of what happened. A lawyer will want to know:

  • what happened, and when;
  • what documents you have;
  • whether you have signed anything;
  • what deadlines may already be running; and
  • what you want to achieve.

This conversation is where the lawyer identifies the issues that matter most. Often they are not the ones the client expected. A severance claim may turn on a single sentence in an employment contract signed years ago. A disability denial may turn on how a doctor filled out one form. An injury claim may depend on a notice that had to be sent within days of the accident.

At Kadish Law, this first review is free, and there is no obligation to retain us afterward.

Step 2: Gathering documents

Good legal work depends on good information. The documents we usually ask for depend on the type of claim.

For severance and wrongful dismissal claims:

  • the termination letter and any severance offer;
  • the employment contract or offer letter, and any amendments;
  • pay stubs, T4 slips and bonus or commission records;
  • benefit, pension and stock plan documents; and
  • any emails or messages about the termination.

For short-term and long-term disability claims:

  • the denial or termination letter;
  • the policy or benefits booklet;
  • claim forms and correspondence with the insurer;
  • medical records, reports and treatment notes; and
  • your job description.

For personal injury and car accident claims:

  • accident reports, photos and witness details;
  • your auto insurance policy and any accident benefits forms;
  • medical records and receipts; and
  • proof of income before the injury.

If you don’t have something, don’t worry. Part of our job is getting the documents that matter, including your claim file from an insurer or records from your doctors.

Step 3: The first formal step

Once we understand the case, the first formal step depends on the type of claim.

In a severance matter, it is usually a demand letter to the employer or its lawyer, explaining what you are owed and why. In a disability matter, it may be an internal appeal to the insurer, or a decision to go straight to a lawsuit. In a car accident case, it often means notifying the insurers involved and making sure accident benefits are in place, while preparing the claim against the at-fault driver.

This step matters because it sets the tone. Employers and insurers tend to respond very differently to a well-supported legal position than to a request from an individual acting alone.

Step 4: Negotiation

Most claims are resolved through negotiation. Offers and counter-offers go back and forth, and we advise you on each one. Some matters resolve within weeks. Others take months, depending on the other side’s approach, the complexity of the case and, in employment cases, whether you have found new work.

You always make the final decision on whether to accept a settlement. Our role is to tell you, honestly, whether an offer is fair and what the risks are of continuing.

Step 5: Starting a claim

If negotiation does not produce a fair result, the next step is usually a lawsuit.

  • Claims of up to $50,000 can be brought in Small Claims Court, which is simpler and generally faster.
  • Larger claims go to the Superior Court of Justice. Claims of up to $200,000 can often use the simplified procedure, which limits some of the steps and costs.

After a claim is started, the parties exchange documents and, in most cases, each side questions the other under oath. This is called examinations for discovery. In Toronto, most civil actions in the Superior Court also go through mandatory mediation, where a neutral mediator helps the parties try to settle.

Starting a claim does not mean the case will go to trial. Many claims settle after discoveries or at mediation, once both sides have seen the evidence.

Step 6: Settlement or trial

The large majority of cases settle before trial. When they don’t, the case is decided by a judge, and sometimes a jury in injury cases. Our lawyers have taken cases to trial when that was what it took, and preparing a case properly for trial from the beginning is often what produces a fair settlement.

How long does it take?

It varies. A straightforward severance negotiation can be resolved in a few weeks. A contested disability or injury claim can take a year or more, especially if it goes through the court process. We give clients a realistic estimate early on, and update it as the case develops. Read more in How Long Does a Severance Claim Take in Ontario?

How legal fees work

People are often surprised to learn how many options there are. The most common fee arrangements are:

  • Hourly rates, where you pay for the time spent on your matter.
  • Flat fees, where a set price covers a defined task, such as reviewing an employment contract.
  • Contingency fees, where the fee is a percentage of the amount recovered, so you pay nothing up front and generally pay no fee if there is no recovery.

Contingency fee agreements in Ontario must be in writing, using the Law Society of Ontario’s standard form. At Kadish Law, our maximum contingency fee is 35%, though in most cases the percentage we charge is lower. The percentage that applies to your matter, how disbursements and HST are handled, and what happens to any legal costs paid by the other side are all set out in writing before you decide to retain us.

Disbursements are out-of-pocket expenses, such as court filing fees, medical records and expert reports. HST applies to legal fees and most disbursements. In Ontario, a party who wins in court is usually awarded part of their legal costs from the other side, and your agreement explains how those costs are treated.

If you have questions about fees, ask. A good lawyer will walk you through an example of what you would take home from a settlement before you sign anything.

What you can do to help your case

  • Keep copies of every document and message related to your claim.
  • Write down a timeline of what happened while your memory is fresh.
  • Follow your medical treatment plan, and keep your appointments.
  • Be careful about what you post on social media.
  • Don’t sign anything from an employer or insurer without advice.
  • In employment cases, keep looking for work and keep a record of your search.
  • Tell your lawyer about any changes, such as a new job, a new diagnosis or a call from the insurer.

Common questions

Do I have to go to court?

Probably not. Most claims settle. If yours goes to court, we prepare you for every step.

Will my employer or insurer know I have a lawyer?

Yes, once we contact them. In our experience, that usually leads to a more serious response.

Can I change my mind?

You can end a retainer, and you always decide whether to accept a settlement. Your agreement explains what happens to fees and disbursements if you change lawyers.

What if I have more than one problem?

That is common. A person let go during a medical leave may have a severance claim and a disability claim at the same time. Because we handle employment, disability and personal injury matters, we can deal with all of it together.

Getting started

If you are dealing with a termination, a disability denial or an injury, the most important step is getting advice before deadlines pass or documents are signed. Use the free case review form on this page, and a lawyer will contact you to discuss your situation.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Every situation is different. Use the free case review form to have a lawyer look at yours.

Not sure if you have a case?

Ask us. The first review is free, and there’s no obligation.

Call us Free case review